Views: 600 Author: Site Editor Publish Time: 2026-11-18 Origin: Site
If your crew runs one C section for most of a shift, manual adjustment may meet every dispatch deadline. If short orders force several size changes before the lorry leaves, ask for a powered option and time the moves your crew actually makes.
Price forming, punching and cutting separately. A machine can punch holes and cut to length automatically while an operator still sets the web, flanges or lips by hand. Start the comparison with two things you already have: your part drawings and a recent shift’s order list.
Give each finished C section its own drawing ID. The web is the broad central face, the flanges turn away from it, and the lips are the short returns at their edges. Show both flange heights and both lip lengths, even when the left and right sides match.
| Drawing ID | Web (mm) | Each flange (mm) | Each lip (mm) |
|---|---|---|---|
| A | 150 | 60 | 15 |
| B | 200 | 60 | 15 |
| C | 200 | 60 | 20 |
Read the table one change at a time. A to B changes only the web. B to C keeps the 200 mm web and changes each lip from 15 to 20 mm. A supplier who confirms the full web range has still to confirm drawing C.
For example, two orders for A followed by one for B mean one cross-section change if you start on A. A new hole pattern on the second A order may still interrupt the line. Record that stop separately so you can price the equipment that would actually shorten it.
Ask the bidder to follow one drawing change through three stations. A controller that stores a part number may recall hole pitch and length. Find out whether selecting that number also moves any forming tools, and who completes the remaining settings.
For each forming axis, distinguish hand setting, powered movement under operator control and automatic positioning from a stored recipe. If the operator jogs a motor to a scale mark, include that time in the trial. For a recipe-controlled axis, ask how the crew confirms the target position before releasing the part.
BMS lists galvanised or cold-rolled sheet at 0.8–2.0 mm for its multi-profile C purlin making machine. The product page describes forming different sizes with the same rollers and spacers, and shows a hydraulic post-cutter.
Match that thickness range to the steel grade and slit width for each drawing you buy. For orders with holes, the BMS C/CU selection guide asks you to specify the punching package. If a quotation says “automatic punching and cutting”, request the list of powered forming axes as a separate item. For drawing C, have the bidder show how both lips reach 20 mm.
Compare both offers against the same drawing revisions. Ask for a move from A to B and back to A to check whether your crew can recover the original settings. If you also buy C, add a B-to-C trial. That move tests a longer lip at a fixed web width.
| Bid item | Manual adjustment | Automatic size change |
|---|---|---|
| Adjustment method | Identify the screws, handwheels or spacers used for each dimension. | Name each powered axis and how the operator selects its position. |
| Size coverage | Mark each drawing achievable with the supplied settings and tools. | Mark each drawing covered by a saved or new recipe. Identify coupled dimensions and exceptions. |
| Tooling | List spacer sets, gauges, punch dies and cut inserts by part ID. | List common tools, plus dies or inserts that still need exchanging. |
| Setup tasks | Show who sets, secures and checks each station. State crew size. | Show who selects the recipe, checks position and finishes any hand settings. |
| Verification | Return to A using the setup sheet and measure the part. Test the lip-only change if C is required. | Recall A and measure the same features. Demonstrate the lip-only change with the quoted axes and tools. |
| Quotation scope | Price the adjustment equipment, tools for every included size and operator training. | Price the powered axes, recipe access, training and support, plus all remaining manual tooling. |
For a manual line, ask a second operator to find the setup sheet for A, identify the spacers and gauges, and locate the settings for the current drawing revision. A common roll set may stay on the mill while several stands still need positioning.
For a powered line, find out who can create, edit and back up a recipe. If only the builder can add a size, ask for the price and lead time. A recipe can recall roll positions while leaving the crew to exchange a punch die or a cut insert.
Ask for the readings on the return to A, alongside the original A readings and drawing limits. If the crew trims a setting after recalling it, log the correction and keep the clock running through approval. Repeat the same transition if you need to see how much the time varies.
Count the transitions in your dispatch order. Two plants buying the same five batches can put quite different values on powered sizing. The difference starts with whether the customer will let you group orders for the same section.
Assume five releases of 40 pieces each in an eight-hour shift, with the line already set for A. Allow 30 minutes per change for manual sizing and 12 minutes for powered sizing in either direction. Both times include any required strip change, tool setting and first-piece approval.
Assume equal running rates and other planned stops. These are calculation inputs for comparing schedules. Replace them with timings from your trials before using the figures in a purchasing decision.
| Shift measure | As ordered | Grouped by size |
|---|---|---|
| Release sequence | A B A B A | A A A B B |
| Size changes | 4 | 1 |
| Manual setup (min) | 4 × 30 = 120 | 1 × 30 = 30 |
| Powered setup (min) | 4 × 12 = 48 | 1 × 12 = 12 |
| Time released (min) | 72 | 18 |
In the alternating shift, manual setup leaves 360 of 480 minutes before other stops. Powered setup leaves 432. Each of the four timed changes already produced one accepted piece. Count those pieces towards the 200 when you estimate the running time still needed.
Grouping the orders cuts the potential gain to 18 minutes. It also leaves the line set for B. Check tomorrow’s first order, today’s dispatch commitments and the space for finished stock before assuming you can run that sequence every day.
Suppose you run 100 alternating shifts a year. The 72-minute difference gives you 120 hours. If only half can replace paid overtime, the cost comparison can use 60 hours at your plant’s actual avoidable overtime cost in ₹ per hour.
For simple payback in years, divide the extra installed price in ₹ by the positive net annual benefit in ₹. If the benefit is zero or negative, the calculation gives no payback period. If urgent-order response still matters, record that reason separately in the purchase approval.
Send one request for quotation (RFQ) with two reply columns, one for operator-set sizing and one for powered sizing. Give both bidders the same drawings and acceptance conditions. If a supplier offers one method only, it can mark the other column unavailable.
When you review a BMS offer, its purlin roll forming machine range can help you identify the product family. Ask every bidder to put the exact model and options beside the price. An offer with powered web adjustment and manual lips belongs in your comparison with both details visible.
Give the supplier a blank record before the demonstration. Agree where to measure along the part, including near the cut end if flare affects fit. For each feature, write the drawing limit next to the actual reading so the person releasing the batch can check it.
Mark each drawing included, available with a priced option, or outside scope. If the die for a required slot is missing, keep that bid’s total open until the price arrives. Then compare the installed cost of two configurations that can complete the same order book.
Choose manual sizing when the line covers your drawings and setup fits the release schedule. Pay for powered sizing where the quoted axes cover the changes you make and the time you recover has value to your plant.
Send BMS your web, flange and lip dimensions, coil grade and thickness, hole drawing, batch sizes, changes per shift and factory electrical supply. Request itemised quotes for the available adjustment methods and a timed demonstration of each type of size change your orders require.